‘Onwards and Sideways’, from the director of ‘Shakespeare in Love’, is a well-intentioned, frequently moving drama about two people diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease who discover that companionship can be both a source of hope and an unexpected complication. It’s also a potentially difficult film to watch, particularly for anybody who has experience of Parkinson’s within their own family.

My principal reservation is that the film sometimes presents an exceptionally bleak picture of the disease’s progression. Parkinson’s affects people in very different ways. Symptoms, rates of progression and responses to medication vary considerably, and not everybody experiences the severe deterioration depicted here. That distinction matters, because while a film has every right to explore the most difficult possibilities, it shouldn’t leave audiences assuming that one person’s experience represents everybody’s future.

Rhys Ifans plays Tony, a deputy headteacher who is diagnosed with Parkinson’s but is determined to keep the news from his colleagues. His reluctance is understandable. He’s frightened not simply of the disease but of how other people might perceive him once they know about it. He worries that the diagnosis will become more important than his professional abilities, that colleagues will begin questioning his competence and that he’ll gradually lose control over his own life.

Ironically, his determination to conceal the condition eventually makes his situation worse. He times his medication around the moments when he most needs to disguise his symptoms, rather than necessarily taking it in the way that would best support his health. The film is particularly effective in showing how stigma can become almost as disabling as the illness itself. Tony meets Emma (Laura Linney), who has received a similar diagnosis but responds in an entirely different way. Where Tony retreats into denial, Emma throws herself into understanding the condition. She reads the literature, attends support groups and eventually discovers a Parkinson’s ballet class.

It’s an appealing contrast. Tony wants to preserve his old life by pretending nothing has changed. Emma tries to construct a new life by acknowledging that everything has. As their friendship develops into romance, the film raises an uncomfortable but legitimate question. Can two people living with a progressive neurological condition realistically support one another, particularly if both may eventually need substantial care themselves?

It’s a question that could easily become patronising, but the film generally treats it with sensitivity. Their relationship is not presented as an inspirational miracle cure. Instead, it becomes a complicated negotiation between affection, independence, vulnerability and practical responsibility.

There are also some unexpectedly revealing details about Parkinson’s itself. The film challenges the assumption that everybody with the condition necessarily experiences a visible tremor, and it explores less widely understood complications, including the impulse-control problems that can be associated with certain medications. Emma develops a gambling addiction, an especially troubling example of how treatment can introduce difficulties quite separate from the symptoms it is intended to alleviate.

Meanwhile, Tony’s physical condition deteriorates. In one distressing sequence, he freezes in the school playground, unable to move. At night, he experiences violent movements and nightmares that leave Emma frightened and unable to help him. For a time, it seems that their relationship simply cannot survive the demands being placed upon it.

Yet there’s a fascinating paradox in Tony’s development. As his body becomes increasingly rigid, his personality begins to soften. The emotionally guarded man we meet at the beginning gradually becomes more expressive, more affectionate and more willing to acknowledge his dependence upon others.

Physically, he’s losing some of his freedom. Emotionally, he’s discovering a freedom he never previously allowed himself. That’s where the film is most affecting. It recognizes that illness doesn’t simply change what somebody can do. It can also change how they relate to other people, and how willing they are to accept love.

I do wish the film had been more careful about balancing its harrowing portrayal of Parkinson’s with the enormous variety of experiences among those living with the condition. Nevertheless, its central relationship is compelling, and its refusal to offer easy solutions gives the story genuine emotional weight. Ultimately, ‘Onwards and Sideways’ suggests that hope doesn’t necessarily mean believing things will get better. Sometimes it means discovering that, even when life becomes harder, there may still be somebody worth sharing it with.

Leave a Reply

Trending